Team Debate
Your judges are volunteers. Some have sat through two hundred rounds and some have never seen one, and you won't know which you've got until you start. Write for the one who has never seen a debate, because the veteran will follow that too. Jargon loses rounds. Signposting wins them.
Speaker one defines the motion and puts your case on the table. Speaker two takes apart what the other side said and adds your second argument. Speaker three rebuts and then weighs, and the fastest way to lose a close round is to let them introduce something new in the last ninety seconds. Sort these roles out before the tournament, not during prep when everyone is panicking.
- Split your prep: two silent minutes where nobody talks and everybody writes, five to pick and build two arguments, four on what the other side will say, three rehearsing your opening twenty seconds out loud.
- Two deep arguments beat five shallow ones. Depth means a mechanism — the actual chain by which the harm happens — plus one named example from the curriculum.
- Weigh out loud, in words a judge can mark: how many people, how badly, how likely, and whether it can be reversed. Say "even if they're right about that, our harm can't be undone and theirs can."
- Rebut in groups, not line by line. "They made three points about the economy and all three assume the market adjusts instantly" buries more than four separate replies would.
- Define your terms in the first thirty seconds, fairly, but in the version of the world that suits you. Nobody wins a round on a definitional fight. People definitely lose them.
- Look up. A speech read word for word off a page scores below a rougher one delivered to someone's face.